(Image credit: Michael Putland/Getty Images)
“There’s a funny sense you get when you first make a record,” Greg Lake told Bass Player back in 2016. “There’s the immediate satisfaction if it’s a hit, but when it stands the test of time, you get a different satisfaction. You see where going the extra mile to make it right really pays off.”
Lake was referring to his work with seminal prog-rock trio Emerson, Lake & Palmer (ELP), whose legacy was built upon the somewhat unlikely success of songs like Lucky Man, Karn Evil 9, Tarkus, and Fanfare for the Common Man.
For Lake, who switched from guitar to bass guitar when he joined, it provided the template for ELP, a band defined not only by the members’ immense musical talent, but also by their deft adaptations of classical music.
King Crimson – 21st Century Schizoid Man (Live at Hyde Park 1969) – YouTube
Watch On
“I was very cavalier when I picked up the bass. They really wanted me as the lead singer, and so Robert said, ‘Would you be prepared to play bass?’ And I thought, ‘Four strings, six strings… what could be the problem?’
All the latest guitar news, interviews, lessons, reviews, deals and more, direct to your inbox!
“Little did I realize that bass playing is an entirely different world; it’s an art form within itself. And although the instruments look similar, they perform a totally different function – they require a different set of skills and knowledge.”
How did you develop your playing style?
The first thing to wake me up to the difference between guitar and bass was the first rehearsal I did with King Crimson. Michael Giles, the drummer, started to bang furiously on his snare, and the whole band stopped.
(Image credit: Rick Diamond/Getty Images)He looked up at me – I’ll never forget the look on his face, a look of pity, sort of annoyed – and he said, ‘Listen, when I play the snare drum, you don’t play. That’s how the snare cuts through.’ It was my first rude awakening to bass playing.
How would you describe your sound and style?
In the beginning, my bass playing was mixed with guitar technique, but the first thing I missed was sustain. I used tape-wound strings, and immediately I found it unrewarding not to be able to sustain a note. And so I soon discovered wire-wound strings, which gave me the sound that I was looking for, which was the low end of a Steinway piano. That’s the sound I wanted.
Do you ever play fingerstyle, or do you always use a pick?
I’m a pick player. When I started playing fingerstyle, it was literally, ‘boom, boom, boom.’ The more percussive way to play was with a pick. And of course, because I played guitar for all those years, I could pick well, so that was my game.
Emerson, Lake & Palmer – Fanfare For The Common Man (Live at Olympic Stadium, Montreal, 1977) – YouTube
Watch On
Would you say it’s more challenging to sing and play bass than to sing and play guitar?
I don’t know about challenging, but it is different. When you play guitar, you have the choice of whether to play or not to play. With bass, you’re going to play whether you like it or not, because you’re part of the rhythm section. If you stop, the whole thing falls apart.
In ELP, you played both bass and guitar. How did you decide which instrument to play on any given song?
I always craved playing the guitar. It’s in my soul, but the problem, when I played guitar, was that the bass went missing. Keith would sometimes try to put bass in, using organ pedals or Moog pedals, but it was never the same.
There’s so much going on between Palmer’s drumming and Emerson’s keyboards. Was it challenging to fit basslines into that milieu?
To be perfectly honest, I did find it challenging with Carl. He doesn’t have what I would call a very solid feel. Technically, he’s incredibly competent – he’s a great, fast, technical drummer – but from a bass player’s standpoint, if I play with someone like Sheila E., for example, or Jeff Porcaro, the floor is really solid.
Carl’s style is based very much on Buddy Rich and jazz, and the tuning of his drums is incredibly high. His kick was more ‘boop, boop’ than ‘thud, thud.’
As a producer I had to work very hard to make the bass and the bass drum marry up. There was a clash that, in a strange way, became the identity of ELP.
You produced the first six ELP records, as well as In the Court of the Crimson King. Would you agree that bass players seem to make good producers?
Maybe there’s some truth to that. You do have a certain perspective as a bass player of what’s going on around you, or maybe it has to do with personality. I didn’t have any ambitions of becoming a famous producer; I just enjoyed doing it. All of the records I produced went platinum, and the ones I didn’t, didn’t.
What separated ELP from the rest of the herd back in the ’70s?
We looked to different roots. Most rock ’n’ roll at that time was based on American blues, gospel and Motown. We didn’t want to be just another band basing ourselves on the same stuff every other band had based their music on. So we looked to European roots rather than American.
(Image credit: Getty Images)We looked to European Folk music, minstrel music, classical music – everything from Greensleeves to Mars, the Bringer of War, because it made our music different. It was a different type of music. I don’t like to say it was better music, because I don’t believe that.
Good-quality blues is as good as Beethoven. But Beethoven is undoubtedly more colourful harmonically, instrumentally, and structurally.
What do you think of music nowadays vs. in the ’60s or ’70s?
In those days, there was a premium on originality. You’ll often hear the word ‘progressive’ used in terms of me. I don’t like that word; it sounds elitist and pretentious. The word ‘original’ – striving for originality – would be far better.
When ELP and King Crimson started, the essence was to be original, to be different. We never thought about being progressive, we thought about being different, and there was a value in that. Nowadays everyone sounds the same.
